Phone: 206 682-4410
Fax: 206 333-1786
Email: Jeffrey@Mirslaw.com

Comparison of Consumer Driven Healthcare Accounts: HSA, HRA, FSA

 
Health
Savings
Account
(HSA)
Health Reimbursement Account
(HRA)
Flexible
Spending
Account
(FSA)
ESTABLISHMENT OF ACCOUNT
• Eligible Individual
• Employer
• Integrate with Employer-Sponsored Cafeteria Plan
Employer-Sponsored Benefit Program
Employer-sponsored Benefit Program via Cafeteria Plan
ACCOUNT TYPE
Trust or Custodial Account
• General Assets of Employer
• Trust
• General Assets of Employer
• Trust
CONTROL AND OWNERSHIP OF ACCOUNT
Employee
Employer
Employer
ACCOUNT PORTABILITY
Yes No No
HIGH DEDUCTIBLE HEALTH PLAN (HDHP) REQUIRED
Yes No No
ELIGIBILITY
• Eligible Individual Covered by HDHP
• Eligible Employee covered by HDHP
Employee Who Meets Employer's Eligibility Criteria Employee Who Meets Employer's Eligibility Criteria
FUNDING
• Individual
• Employee salary reduction dollars
• Employer
• Third party
Strictly by Employer • Employee Salary Reduction Dollars
• Employer
ACCOUNT LIMITS
Individual
Lesser of

Deductible Amount ($1,050+) or $2,700 (for 2006)

Family
Lesser of

Deductible Amount ($2,100+) or $5,450 (for 2006)
No statutory required limit No statutory required limit
ANNUAL OUT OF POCKET LIMITS
• $5,250 Individual
• $10,500 Family
n/a n/a
REQUIRED PRE-FUNDING
Yes No No
DISBURSEMENT OF MONEY
Checks, debit card Reimburse through Employer Checks, Debits, Withdrawal Slips
QUALIFIED MEDICAL EXPENSES
• Qualified medical expenses as defined in IRC §213(d), including over-the-counter drugs
• Retiree health insurance premium other than Medicare supplement policies
• COBRA premium
• Long term care (LTC) insurance premium
• Health insurance premium if receiving unemployment
Not permitted:
• Any other type of health insurance premium
• Qualified medical expenses as defined in IRC §213(d), including over-the-counter drugs
• Health insurance premium, including LTC premium

• Qualified Medical Expenses as defined in IRC §213(d), including over-the-counter drugs

Not permitted:
• Health insurance premium, including LTC insurance premium
TAX TREATMENT OF CONTRIBUTIONS
• Individual's contributions to own HSA tax-deductible
• Employee-Contributions to Employee's own HSA are Tax-Deductible
• Employer-Contributions to Employee's HSA (with or without cafeteria plan) with salary reduction dollars:

    - Deductible by        Employer

    - Excludable
       from
       Employee's
       gross income
• Only Employer Contributions permitted:

    - Deductible
       by Employer

    - Excludable
       from Employee's        gross income
• Only Employer Contributions permitted:

    - Deductible
       by Employer

    - Excludable
       from Employee's        gross income
TAXATION OF INTEREST OR DIVIDEND ACCUMULATION
Tax-free n/a n/a
CONSEQUENCES OF CASHING-OUT ACCOUNT FOR NON-QUALIFIED MEDICAL EXPENSES

Distributions are taxed as income and subject to 10% penalty tax, except following:

  • Death
  • Disability
  • Attainment of Medicare eligibility age
No cash-out option available Some (Section 125 Rules apply)
CARRY-OVER OF FUNDS PERMITTED
Yes Yes
(Employer decides)
No
DEATH OF ACCOUNT HOLDER
Surviving spouse only (if designated beneficiary) entitled to use remaining account monies for qualified medical expenses Eligible Dependents entitled to use remaining account monies for qualified medical expenses, in accordance with the plan document Eligible Dependents entitled to use remaining account monies for qualified medical expenses, in accordance with the plan document
APPLICABILITY OF ERISA
No Yes Yes
SUBJECT TO COBRA
  • No, if not Employer-based
  • Unclear, if Employer-based
Yes Yes
EFFECTIVE DATE
1/1/2004 6/26/2002 3/7/1989

Note: # Indexed annually; plus there is an additional catch-up provision for individuals 55+ years, $700 in 2006 increasing $100 per year to $1,000 in 2009 and thereafter.   

RETURN TO TOP


Please Choose A Focus Area:

  Home  | Get to Know Jeff |   Legal Links    | Map to Office  | Contact Us  | Disclaimer